Price: $666,000
Location: Punta Gorda, FL
Welcome to Phantom's Rest, a one-of-a-kind waterfront mansion steeped in history, charm, and just a touch of supernatural flair. Nestled in the heart of Punta Gorda’s eeriest enclave, this sprawling 6-bedroom, 4-bath home is not just a residence—it’s an experience!
The Property
Upon entering, you’ll be greeted by a grand staircase that supposedly has a penchant for creaking… but only after midnight. Don’t be alarmed, it’s just the friendly spirit of former sea captain Bartholomew Blackwater, who, rumor has it, still keeps a lookout for storms (or unannounced visitors).
Original wood flooring throughout the home? Yes. Slightly squeaky? Absolutely. In fact, the ambiance of the dining room is enhanced by an old chandelier that flickers during full moons and occasional thunderstorms. This isn’t just mood lighting—it’s mysterious lighting.
Unique Features
-
Master Bedroom: Wake up to views of the bay… and perhaps the occasional wispy figure of Eleanor, the 19th-century resident who has a habit of rearranging flowers. She only picks orchids.
-
Gourmet Kitchen: Perfect for whipping up a feast or an old potion—either works. The stove tends to heat up on its own, which we assume means dinner will never be late.
-
Basement Wine Cellar: Rumored to be the hiding place of Blackbeard’s lost treasure, but most homeowners just use it for Pinot Noir.
-
Wrap-Around Veranda: Ideal for watching sunset views of the bay—or the eerie fog that rolls in on Fridays the 13th.
Amenities Include:
-
Private dock (though beware of the occasional unexplained ripple in the water)
-
A hidden library (complete with books that occasionally open on their own—great for automatic research on the supernatural!)
-
Walking distance to charming downtown Punta Gorda—perfect for daytime strolls. Just make sure you’re back before dusk!
This home offers more than just incredible views and a spacious floor plan—it promises intrigue, adventure, and an unshakable feeling that you’re never truly alone. But isn’t that what makes a house a home?
Call today to book your tour… if you dare.
About the author: With nearly 10 years of experience as a full-time, licensed Realtor - and now a Broker-Associate - Makala is always looking for new and innovative ways to provide our clients with the best possible service. Makala obtained her Bachelor's in Education, and enjoys using her skills to educate buyers and sellers about the ever-changing market to make sound real estate investments. You may also find her showing property, staging new listings, and streamlining the team’s workflow.
Originally from the Finger Lakes area of New York, she moved to Florida at a very young age and currently lives in Punta Gorda. She enjoys visiting Punta Gorda's waterfront parks, attending food and art festivals in Fort Myers, and going dancing with friends.
